Our Latest Online Backup Reviews:Vembu SyncBlaze
Industry LinksTools and Graphs
02 Dec 2007
Backup Review Rating:
(3 stars out of possible 5)
Please click here to view this review in PDF format
It’s not clear that SwapDrive really wants to be in the market of selling directly
Overall we gave SwapDrive 3 stars as a backup service. They put a lot of work
Location: Washington, DC
From the website:
Getting started and initial backup
It doesn’t appear that SwapDrive is very serious about attracting individual users through its web interface. Beyond pricing (which is off the scale compared with their competitors), they have no free trial whatsoever, so you have to put in your credit card even to try it. When we tried it, the signup process produced an error. Once you enter your credit card, you get an order confirmation screen:
Clicking the “Go to Your Account” button resulted in a web error:
We were able to go to their home page and log in. However, we noticed that the default for login is not a secure https link, but rather regular old http — not a good practice. If you want to log in securely, you have to click a “Secure” button as shown below. Problem is, it didnâ€™t work.
Selecting the “Secure” login brings up a dialog box then an invalid User ID/password error:
SwapDrive’s backup is fairly simple. Once you have installed the PC software, you have a choice of ways to select what you want to back up. The “Basic” choice, which is probably what most people would choose, would be a lot better if it backed up your whole Documents & Settings folder, not just you’re My Documents folder. The “Basic” setting would miss your desktop and many other settings files that you’d probably like to recover in the event of a disaster.
You can click the “Advanced” option and select folders and files yourself, as shown:
It’s tempting to just want to backup the whole “My Documents” and “Desktop” folders. For this test, we bought the 100MB for $7.50 per month plan.
First, beware of security. By default, your files will not be encrypted unless you set that option on the Advanced tab. The interface warns that if you want to access your files using their web interface, the backup can be neither encrypted or compressed. If you are backing up any sensitive, such as Quicken files or email, you would certainly want to turn on encryption. Unfortunately, then, you won’t be able to use the web interface to restore these files.
There is an editor that lets you set up rules for what is included and excluded. We view this as being far too techie for the average consumer user:
There is also a scheduling screen that lets you select when you want to back up. Scheduled back ups are not as convenient as continuous backup. Some of the services we tested back up continuously in the background, automatically adjusting CPU utilization to whatever else is happening on the PC. The problem with backing up at say 1:30 AM is that you have to leave your computer on and connected. If you get disconnected from the Internet, then your backup doesn’t happen. If you’re traveling, your access to the Internet is unpredictable. It’s nice to know that backup happens automatically whenever you’re connected to the Internet. We don’t know why services like SwapDrive still force users to make these unnecessary scheduling decisions.
For my first test, we selected files that totaled 133MB– more than my 100MB quota. Sooner or later, you’re going to add enough files to your backed up folders that you will hit the quota, so we wanted to see what happens.
When we tried to back up the 133MB, it started but then gave us an error message:
Neither the error message or the error log explained that the error was due to being over quota, however. We tried again and this time it worked. When SwapDrive came to a file that would put the user over quota, it would try to backup that file four times (with pauses of 2, 8 and 32 seconds between retries), then go to the next file; this continued until it found files small enough to fit in the remaining space. The problem with this is that the user would really have no idea what was backed up and what wasn’t unless they went and looked.
Once the backup went over quota, the status window froze. There were no changes over several hours. However, Windows Task Manager did not show the application as “Not Responding”. The application just sat there until we killed it.
We reduced the size of our backup set so that it was less than 100MB. This wasn’t so easy because the client did not update the “space required” number. Restarting the application, however, produced the right number and the backup appeared to have completed successfully.
The web interface worked, but it’s mostly useful for accessing individual files. The “uploading” part of the web interface is clearly oriented toward backing up individual files. It has no encryption or compression. It looks a lot like the photo-sharing web sites like Flickr where you browse for a few files to upload:
Uploading a large file that pushed me over the quota produced a strange result:
The “thermometer” indicated that we had backed up 104% of quota. However, the file was not actually backed up.
The drag and drop interface worked as you would expect, except that it didn’t work with Firefox.
PC Magazine reviewed SwapDrive in 2004 and gave them 3 ½ stars out of 5. In 2004 this was probably a fair evaluation considering that current market leaders Carbonite and Mozy weren’t even around back then. Today their product doesn’t stack up quite so well any more.
On the plus side, SwapDrive has been around for at least 7 or 8 years, so the service is mature enough that it ought to be pretty reliable. We didn’t get any hint of instability in their server software. However, since it has been around for a long time, it’s starting to look a little long in the tooth compared with some of the other services we tested. Also we wouldn’t be surprised if they had a relatively high cost infrastructure based on technology designed many years ago. That’s only speculation, however. On their website they allude to redundant data storage– if they really mean a second copy, this is not a very cost-effective way to achieve high reliability.
For the consumer or small business seeking out a service for their own use, SwapDrive is not the right product, at least not if you are buying it directly from SwapDrive’s web site. They claim to offer Swapdrive under 60 partners’ brands, including:
We haven’t heard of most of these, but you can chase them down on the web if you’re interested.
Please click here to view this review in PDF format
General Tags: online backup reviews, online backup, online backup services, SaaS, online file backup, online file storage, data storage, cloud computing, compare online backups, online backup providers directory, software as a service, online backup companies, online data backup, online backup news, backing up online, CEO interviews, top rated online backups, data security